Government & Politics  October 3, 2025

Editorial: Colorado property owners face another budget hit – rising insurance costs

Colorado property owners face a stark reality when balancing their household budgets: Property and casualty insurance no longer constitutes a routine line item, with homeowners in the state paying among the highest premiums in the nation.

That fact is made abundantly clear in the 2025 P&C Insurance Report prepared by the Metro Denver Economic Development Corp., which found a distressing pattern of escalating risk from natural disasters, increased home values, rising premiums and reinsurance costs, and a contracting insurer presence.

Exacerbating the problem are regulatory, legislative and legal risks that potentially make the state less hospitable to providers.

The situation is dire. From wildfires to floods to hailstorms, natural disasters have increased exponentially in recent decades. Colorado experienced five natural disasters in the 1980s, jumping to 21 events in just the first four years of the 2020s.

And the cost of those disasters has soared, now averaging between $1.7 billion and $4 billion annually. Costs totaled $500 million for the 2012 Waldo Canyon Fire, $2.3 billion for the 2017 Denver hailstorm and $2 billion for the 2021 Marshall Fire.

Homeowners’ insurance premiums increased 30% from 2019 to 2023, according to the study, with Colorado homeowners paying an average annual rate of $4,072, sixth-highest in the nation below Florida, $10,996; Louisiana, $6,354; Oklahoma, $5,444; Texas, $4,456; and Mississippi, $4,312 — all well above the U.S. average of $2,377.

Costs vary wildly across the state, with Pueblo the highest at $4,730 and Fort Collins and Longmont the lowest at $3,745 and $3,737, respectively. But adjusted premiums, which account for the median home price in each city, more accurately reflect the cost burden for homeowners, the report states.

That means that although Pueblo reports the highest average premium, the relatively low median home price in the city results in an adjusted premium of just $2,468, compared with Boulder’s adjusted premium of $7,877, the highest in the state.

All of these issues have caused homeowners insurance lines to record a loss ratio of 106.9% in 2023, “signaling deep unprofitability,” the report states, with insurers losing money in eight of the past 11 years.

And although natural disasters and inflation contribute heavily to the problem, governmental regulation also plays a significant role, with well-meaning measures sometimes leading to unintended consequences.

So what is Colorado to do? It’s clear that the state should find a proper balance between protecting consumers and preserving a viable insurance marketplace, looking to other states that have grappled with issues of rising premiums, risk and loss of insurers. Governmental policies should not drive insurers away or raise barriers to entry.

“Colorado’s insurance market is in a vulnerable state, shaped by growing climate risks and legislative overreach,” the report states. “With premiums rising and insurers pulling back, policymakers must act carefully to ensure future affordability and access. A balanced, collaborative approach is essential to preserve a competitive, resilient insurance market.”

Related Posts

Sign up for BizWest Daily Alerts
Closing in 8 seconds...