October 20, 2026

Arnolfo’s book details what put Silver Grill on a roll

FORT COLLINS — For more than four decades behind the counter at Fort Collins’ iconic Silver Grill, John Arnolfo watched his business and Old Town change and grow. Now, the cafe’s former owner is sharing those experiences in a new book about its colorful history – including how it built an identity based on cinnamon rolls that started out “as hard as hockey pucks.”

“The Silver Grill Cafe: An American Story and Counter Seat to Fort Collins History” is on sale in paperback, tabletop book and ebook formats at the cafe, 218 Walnut St., or through Amazon or Arnolfo’s website, JohnArnolfo.com.

He’ll be signing copies at an event to be held from noon to 2 p.m. Nov. 8 in the teaching kitchen at Ginger and Baker, 359 Linden St., at which he and that restaurant’s owner, Ginger Graham, will swap tales about Silver Grill and Old Town’s history.

One story that’s sure to come up is how Arnolfo, seven years after buying the cafe in 1979, came up with the aromatic treat that built its reputation.

“I felt like I needed a signature item to succeed,” he said. With area eateries such as Vern’s in Laporte and Johnson’s Corner in Johnstown gaining fame with their cinnamon rolls, Arnolfo decided to dive into the competition himself.

“I felt like I could become the cinnamon roll king of downtown Fort Collins,” he said, “so I went to a Better Homes and Gardens cookbook for the dough recipe. In May 1986 I baked 18 cinnamon rolls, but I didn’t allow them to proof properly, and they came out hard as hockey pucks. But my customers still ate them.”

Arnolfo turned to retired German baker Russ Hamilton for help, he said, “and within a month I was selling dozens. He turned me from a home baker to a commercial baker, and after the first year of selling them, Silver Grill’s gross sales went up by 50%.”

Today, Silver Grill sells more than 15,000 cinnamon rolls a month.

“Businesses need identity. Now they’re calling it branding,” Arnolfo said, “but you need that special something that makes people want to come back.”

That’s just one of the lessons about entrepreneurship that running the Silver Grill taught Arnolfo. He worked as a ditchdigger, waiter, real estate agent and gravesite salesman while attending Colorado State University, and first sat at the grill’s worn linoleum counter during his senior year.

After earning his degree and spending four years in Vail, Arnolfo and college roommate Mike Gress looked for a restaurant to buy. They learned that the Silver Grill, which had opened in 1933, was for sale. Despite equipment that had not been maintained for years and walls that were moist and discolored from years of grease and tobacco smoke, they made an offer on the spot with loans from their parents in February 1979.

Leonidas “Flossie” Widger, right, poses behind the counter at the Silver Grill with his son and daughters just after he opened the restaurant in 1933. Courtesy John Arnolfo

“Our first day,” Arnolfo recalled, “we’re driving into work and I looked at Mike and he looked at me and said ‘Who’s going to cook?’ We had worked in restaurants, we’d always been waiters. But Mike was applying to be a paramedic, so I said, ‘I’m going to be there most of the time. Why don’t I cook, and you help me for the first couple weeks.’

“We’d never cooked breakfast before,” Arnolfo said. “We’d never flipped an egg before. So that first morning, if we could flip an egg without breaking it, we cheered. We didn’t know how to cook, but the Silver Grill was small enough that we could learn.

“We cooked 12 breakfasts that day, we grossed $166, and we thought we had hit a home run,” he said. “Now, its daily sales are in five figures, and on a busy weekend day they’ll do over 1,300 breakfasts.”

After three years, Arnolfo bought Gress out and eventually expanded the cafe into four additional buildings.

When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, the restaurant was forced to close for a total of 191 days in the first year, but with the help of the federal government’s Payroll Protection Plan loans, Arnolfo said, “I knew I would survive and keep my employees.

“I used a pedicab to deliver cinnamon rolls to the fire department, the police department, and any business that was open,” he said. “My main goal was to make sure that people knew the Silver Grill was still open and would be there when COVID was over. That proved to be very successful for me.”

The lesson from the pandemic, he said, was perseverance, the same ideal that has kept the cafe thriving.

“How do you survive in a 93-year-old business through hard times and great times? You always do what you say you’re going to do,” Arnolfo said. “It’s a story of risk, reward and success in the end.”

When Arnolfo was preparing to retire, he was approached by Alan Jantzen, who bought Silver Grill in 2021 and continues to operate it along with his wife, Jackie.

“It was really important to me that he carried on the legacy of the Silver Grill,” Arnolfo said. “After five years he recognizes and appreciates what the Silver Grill was, what it is and what it can be in the future.”

Arnolfo’s fondest memory, and what he describes in a book that he originally thought would just be a pamphlet but that grew just like his cinnamon-roll business, is of his customers.

“It’s the people,” he said. “Old Town was an area that had been forgotten in time. What I loved about it was the salt-of-the-earth people. The regulars at the Silver Grill – I call them the ‘regular regulars’ – were the blue-collar workers that owned car-repair shops, glass companies, shoe repairs, retailers, farmers and ranchers. I really had a connection with them.

“And I loved the old style,” he said. “It’s a Colorado cafe: no glitz, no glory. The people who supported me really wanted me to succeed. I was a young man, probably a little arrogant from my years of working in Vail, certainly naive. But they saw the qualities of my desire to succeed, and they supported me.”

Version 1.0.0

For more than four decades behind the counter at Fort Collins’ iconic Silver Grill, John Arnolfo watched his business and Old Town change and grow. Now, the cafe’s former owner is sharing those experiences in a new book about its colorful history – including how it built an identity based on cinnamon rolls that started out “as hard as hockey pucks.”

With BizWest since 2012 and in Colorado since 1979, Dallas worked at the Longmont Times-Call, Colorado Springs Gazette, Denver Post and Public News Service. A Missouri native and Mizzou School of Journalism grad, Dallas started as a sports writer and outdoor columnist at the St. Charles (Mo.) Banner-News, then went to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch before fleeing the heat and humidity for the Rockies. He especially loves covering our mountain communities.

Related Posts

Sign up for BizWest Daily Alerts
Closing in 8 seconds...