Weld County’s options may be limited on judicial-center vote
State mandate for new court facilities supersedes county charter, attorney says
GREELEY — A provision in the Weld County Charter that restricts large capital expenditures without voter approval may not apply to Weld County’s proposed $334 million judicial center, county attorneys told elected officials Thursday.
During a joint work session of the Weld County Board of Commissioners and Weld County Council, County Attorney Bruce Barker argued that state requirements governing judicial facilities supersede the charter provision because the county is legally obligated to provide adequate court facilities.
“If you look at the determination by the state judicial that says, ‘Current facilities are unsuitable, and you’ve got to build a new one that makes it suitable,’ there is no mechanism to take it to a vote,” Barker told the combined boards. “You have to do this.”
That interpretation could determine whether voters get a chance to weigh in on Weld County’s portion of the planned Downtown Civic Campus, which includes a new county judicial center and parking garage, as well as a new administration building for Greeley-Evans School District 6, a new Greeley City Hall and other municipal facilities.
The county’s share of the project is estimated at $334.1 million, well above the spending limit established under Section 14-8 of the Weld County Charter. The provision limits capital expenditures to an amount equal to the revenue generated by a three-mill property-tax levy over three years, currently about $177 million.
In May, commissioners voted 3-2 to divide the judicial-center project into three phases: core and shell construction, a parking structure and tenant improvements. By separating the work into multiple contracts, no individual phase would exceed the charter threshold requiring voter approval.
That approach prompted criticism from some residents, commissioners and members of the Weld County Council, an elected body that operates as a watchdog over Weld County government. The council in May threatened to seek an injunction against the commissioners if the judicial center project were not taken to voters, according to reporting by the Greeley Tribune.
Barker argued that the charter debate may ultimately be moot because the county has a legal obligation to provide facilities that meet state judicial standards.
The Office of the State Court Administrator has determined that Weld County’s current facilities are “unsuitable for present and future administration of justice in Weld County,” according to materials presented Thursday.
A state needs assessment completed in May determined that the county eventually will require 35 courtrooms, up from 23 today, and 530 parking spaces. Weld County’s population is projected to reach 479,000 by 2040, up from 379,000 today.
Commissioners in April approved plans for a six-story, 281,405-square-foot Justice Center with 24 courtrooms, with the ability to expand to 33 courtrooms. The facility would reflect the latest standards in design of judicial centers, including separate circulation paths for inmates, the public and judicial staff.
County Facilities Director Patrick O’Neill said renovating the existing Weld County Centennial Center — originally built as a jail and eventually converted into court space — would cost roughly $100 million while adding only two courtrooms and would still fail to address long-term needs.
“It’s a great expense to meet what we need right now,” O’Neill said. “It doesn’t account for future growth. … It’s a huge expense to retrofit that building, and it gets us to meet the current need right now. It doesn’t get us into the future.”
Barker said only the Board of County Commissioners and the Colorado chief justice have authority to determine whether judicial facilities are adequate.
“I know that this is hard to understand, but it’s not the voters who say what’s suitable,” Barker said. “This is a mandatory obligation. … Under a mandatory obligation, you can’t say, ‘No, our charter says this.’”
The discussion left some elected officials uneasy.
Commissioner Scott James said commissioners must weigh their obligation to adhere to the provisions of the charter against the likelihood that the county would lose a legal challenge if it failed to provide facilities mandated by the state.
He called the funding of judicial facilities “the largest unfunded mandate” imposed by the state on the county.
“I don’t know that we have a say in the matter,” he said. “That’s what’s frustrating.”
Commissioners are expected to discuss the path forward at one of their meetings next week.
A provision in the Weld County Charter that restricts large capital expenditures without voter approval may not apply to Weld County’s proposed $334 million judicial center, county attorneys told elected officials Thursday.


