Banking & Finance  November 22, 2026

‘A really disruptive year’

Mergers, acquisitions continue to dominate state’s banking sector

Colorado’s banking industry has seen quite a bit of repositioning in the past couple of years, with some high-profile mergers and acquisitions and new banks entering the playing field. For locally owned banks, the biggest ripple came from PNC Bank’s acquisition of FirstBank of Colorado, the state’s largest locally owned bank. The deal closed in January 2026, and Pittsburgh-based PNC began the process of merging the two institutions.

Kevin Classen, former CEO and president of FirstBank and now Colorado regional president and mountain territory executive for PNC, said it has been an “incredibly successful conversion as conversions go.”

The company brought in 600 legacy PNC employees in June to help FirstBank branches transition over to PNC.  

“As with anything, you will have some level of disruption with people, moving them into new systems. We saw that with the FDIC reporting. We slipped a bit in those rankings,” Classen said. “Some of that is disappointing but always to be expected on some level. What we are taking heart in, and feeling good about, is we retained over 95% of our customers, consumers and businesses. Some of the dollars went out, we don’t like that, but it is sort of to be expected.”

According to the FDIC’s Deposit Market Share report for June 30, 2026, PNC’s  market share in Boulder, Larimer and Weld counties declined from a year earlier when compared with the combined 2025 market share of PNC and FirstBank. In Boulder County, its combined market share with FirstBank decreased from 15.38% to 12.59%, a decline of 2.79 percentage points. In Larimer County, it declined from 11.06% to 9.08%, a decline of 1.98 percentage points. In Weld County, it declined from 10.15% to 9.3%, a decline of 0.85 percentage points.

In Broomfield County, where PNC reported no deposits before the acquisition, FirstBank’s market share fell from 16.34% in June 2025 to 13.42% under PNC a year later, a decline of 2.92 percentage points.

The bank is now focused on getting its former FirstBank employees comfortable with its products and up to speed on everything before it turns “back on the offense to go deeper with clients in our market. Retaining 95% is critical to that mission. All-in-all, I think it has gone very well and there’s a lot more to come in terms of what we are capable of and committed to in Colorado and certainly Northern Colorado.” 

PNC has roughly 100 branches in Colorado. It did close 14 PNC locations that overlapped with legacy FirstBank locations. Some newer FirstBank branches were closed but those employees were moved to nearby PNC branches, Classen said.

“We did retain a high percentage of people. From day one we felt that was so important for continuity,” he said.

An opportunity

Many local banks looked at the merger as an opening for community banks to step up and differentiate themselves from the large regional and national players. Others believe, a year in, that the merger might not have created as much of an opportunity as they thought it would.

“It has been a really disruptive year” when it comes to mergers and acquisitions, said Matt Teeters, chief retail officer for Alpine Bank in Denver. “FirstBank was the most significant because of how big a community bank they were. Every time you see a merger like this occur the rest of the banking industry determines how to capitalize on this level of disruption.”

Glenwood Springs-based Alpine Bank is now the largest bank headquartered in Colorado, and it has spent a good amount of time trying to figure out how to differentiate itself from the competition and benefit from FirstBank’s exit from the market. 

Alpine’s founder came from FirstBank in 1965, so Alpine kept a close relationship with that bank over the years. And out of all the competition, Alpine is the most similar to FirstBank, Teeters said, so “how do we get that message out broadly to the customer base that would find us appealing? We have seven locations on the Front Range. We were not as well prepared to capitalize on that as we would like.”

Alpine has one branch in Fort Collins and one in Boulder. Teeters said that he hopes to open five new locations in the next two years, including two in Boulder County, two in Larimer County and one in Weld County.

Teeters added that Alpine is “no longer growing robustly on market share, and deposits flatlined as a state” so the only option for growth is to move into new markets such as Longmont, Loveland and Greeley.

Nathan Ewert, senior vice president of consumer banking at FNBO, said that “banking in Colorado is changing the same way it’s changing across the country. Colorado continues to be a growing and attractive market, so it is no surprise there is a lot of activity here.”

Omaha, Nebraska-based First National of Nebraska and its subsidiary FNBO announced the acquisition of Denver-based InBankshares Corp. in September. 

“Consolidation is just part of this industry, and we are part of that, too,” Ewert said. “Any time a bank changes hands, some customers will take a fresh look at their relationship. Some will stay, but it creates an opportunity for some customers to explore.”

He added that what hasn’t changed is that people in Northern Colorado still want relationships. “They want local decision-making and a bank that shows up for their community. At FNBO, that is where we put our energy. We have been in Northern Colorado for more than 30 years, and our growth here is a sign of how committed we are to this region.”

Even though FNBO is headquartered in Nebraska, decisions about what happens in Colorado are made by people who know these communities and invest a lot locally, Ewert said. FNBO is a family-owned bank that has been around since 1857. 

“We understand what it means to build something for the long haul and that dovetails with this acquisition,” Ewert said. 

InBank has nine branches in Colorado, including one in Superior, and four in New Mexico. After the merger is complete, FNBO will have 30 bank branches in Colorado.

Shawn Osthoff, president of Bank of Colorado, believes the disruption in the market brought about by all of the mergers and acquisitions is a good thing. “It creates opportunity when there is disruption in the market,” he said.

Bank of Colorado is a family-owned-and-managed subsidiary of Nebraska-based Pinnacle Bancorp Inc. The bank, which has branches in Boulder, Larimer and Weld counties, has seen its market share increase slightly in all of its Northern Colorado service areas but, in general, deposits are relatively flat because of tariffs, which compress deposit growth, and Paycheck Protection Program funds which boosted deposits when they were first made but have started moving out of more traditional banks. 

“It is interesting times with the stock market and treasury rates jumping up. The stock market has done well, and I think people are looking at other investments to put some of that liquidity to good use, which is good for our overall economy,” Osthoff said.

He added that Bank of Colorado is just trying to make sure the market knows who they are.

“When we say we are a community bank it means we do the best we can to serve the communities we are in and share our resources to do significant projects,” he said.

Gerard Nalezny, chairman and CEO of Verus Bank of Commerce in Fort Collins, said that his bank is “having one of our better years in a while. On the loan side, we are up double digits.”

He believes that bump in activity is not related to any one specific issue.

“I think it is because we have a specific niche. We are a small community bank. We play in the crumbs that fall off the table of the big boys,” he said. “We can’t compete with big national players with the stuff in their breadbasket. We have to look at one offs that don’t fit in their box, and we’ve seen more of that.”

Particularly in commercial real estate, there are a lot of adjustable-rate loans. Many of those originated at the bottom of the rate cycle, when rates were at 3.5%. Now that rates are up to nearly 8%, “those people are looking for options,” he said. 

Verus specializes in real estate deals under $10 million, working with non-institutional loans that have 25-year amortization, 10-year balloon or five-year ARMs, which “creates opportunities for refinance,” he said.

“Our market in Northern Colorado is pretty solid, regardless of all the noise out there. If you look at the real estate statistics in terms of office, retail and industrial in terms of occupancies, they are all pretty high. We see some refinance activity, some new activity and for our particular circumstances, we are seeing more loans or relationships that fit our niche of being able to do something that doesn’t fit the box but still makes sense,” Nalezny said.

The PNC acquisition of FirstBank not only opens up opportunities for smaller banks in the region, but larger players as well, he added. Some of the larger banks, such as KeyBank or Chase, might see their market share fall a bit with the addition of a new competitor. 

“There will be a shuffling of decks as that plays out,” he said.

Colorado’s banking industry has seen quite a bit of repositioning in the past couple of years, with some high-profile mergers and acquisitions and new banks entering the playing field. For locally owned banks, the biggest ripple came from PNC Bank’s acquisition of FirstBank of Colorado, the state’s largest locally owned bank. The deal closed in January 2026, and Pittsburgh-based PNC began the process of merging the two institutions.

Related Posts

Sign up for BizWest Daily Alerts
Closing in 8 seconds...